October 16, 2026

10 Cozy Books to Read This Fall | Fall Reading List

Fall is the beginning of my favorite time of the year and my favorite hobbies are reading books and watching Hallmark. This is my first year setting a reading goal for myself and I actually have a list! Discover 10 cozy books to add to your TBR, from sweet romance and cozy mysteries to feel-good reads perfect for a relaxing day.

DISCLAIMER: Cozy is a feeling for me. The setting, the cover art, the time of year, the MC chemistry- each of these things can make me feel cozy. Sometimes the books contain mild language, spice, or adult themes. I read based off the vibes, but excessive language, spice that involves multiple persons or assault, spice that promotes promiscuity and not commitment to one person, and LGBTQIA+ themes are a hard pass for me. All books will have content disclaimers so that you can decide whether it is right for you or not. 

5 Cozy Books I Have Read This Fall 📚🍂

  • A Weather Girl's Guide to Love by Cassandra Joelle: 
RomCom, Christian Fiction, Romance 
Hailey Sinclair is an aspiring meteorologist with her future plans all mapped out, but God abruptly derails those plans. Hailey follows her boyfriend, Jett Dawson, back to his hometown in Wyoming to face tragedy in the hopes that this is just temporary. Still chasing her weather girl dreams, Hailey becomes the town's local meteorologist- with cameraman Colt by her side. She has to navigate between the future she had planned and the current circumstances God has her living in order to decide what her future really looks like. 

  • Hearts in Circulation by Sarah Monzon: 
Christian Fiction, Contemporary Romance
Hayley Holt is the local librarian- and she is going mobile! Think, van life, but with a van full of books. She loves her job and she loves serving her community. After health complications give her a new lease on life, Hayley takes the mobile library to a neighboring town when a rock slide leaves her stranded. The local recluse mechanic, Levi Redding, rescues her and provides her with room and board while he repairs the van. The two form an unlikely friendship that quickly grows into a more intimate bond. 

  • The Bodyguard's Fall by Cindy Steel: 
Contemporary Romance, RomCom
Olivia is a screenwriter for network murder mysteries. Blood, gore, dead bodies- she's got you covered. However, the network is pivoting into a more family friendly genre (think Hallmark) because of previous negative PR coverage. She has no idea what to do with pumpkin patches, flannel shirts, and happily ever after. But, now, she's apparently living her own mystery when a stalker begins having inside details to her life. In an attempt to save her life, Olivia's cop big brother sends her to Autumn Ridge where his cop best friend, Tate Walker, can keep her safe. Unfortunately, the threats only ramp up. Olivia and Tate are getting desperate to catch her stalker- what are they going to do?

  • The Pumpkin Spice Cafe by Laurie Gilmore: 
Contemporary Romance, Spicy Romance
Jeanie inherits her aunt's cozy cafe after she decides to retire and do some traveling. Once the shock wears off, Jeanie is actually excited to start a new life and make new friends. However, she starts noticing almost immediately what she perceives to be sabotage from someone potentially close to her new inheritance. Logan lives with his grandparents, who have raised him since he was a young boy, on their farm and help support the town with local produce and fall festivity needs. Living in a small town has it's perks- but gossip is not one that he is especially fond of not does he care to take part in, if he can help it. He becomes intrigued with Jeanie being new in town, but also afraid to get too interested because the past has a funny way of repeating itself and she may run back to the big city she just fled from. Are they destined for one another? Can they put their insecurities aside and move forward to a future in this small town together?

  • Chocolate Chip Cookie Murder by Joanne Fluke: 
Mystery
Hannah owns the local cafe and bakery, The Cookie Jar in small town Lake Eden. Everybody knows everybody and their day to day routine. So, when a new eligible bachelor pops into town, Hannah's mother is relentless in her pursuit to marry her almost thirty-year-old daughter off. However, Hannah has her two sisters active lives and one spunky niece that keeps her fulfilled enough to where marriage is not exactly the dream right now. But, on another ordinary and routine morning to work, Hannah starts noticing unpredictable patterns around town that leads to the murder of one of Lake Eden's own beloved resident, Hannah becomes a super sleuth to help her detective brother in law solve this murder. 

2 Books I Did Not Finish 😬📚

  • The New Girl by R.L. Stine: 
Horror Fiction, Young Adult, Suspense, Thriller
Cory Brooks becomes increasingly intrigued with the new girl at school, Anna Corwin. Immediately, something is just not right with her, but he just can't put his finger on what. Sure, she dresses differently and her physical appearance is obviously more glowing- but it can't be more than that, right? When his friends start acting weird about his new girl obsession, he decides it's time to find out what the mystery is surrounding this new girl- like why he can't seem to ever find her around school and why he knocked on her door to hear her family say she was dead! 

I loved the Fear Street series as a tween/teen. The stories were so creepy at that age, I would be up all night with the heebie jeebies. There's a reason I still don't sleep with my foot hanging off the bed or wander into dark rooms alone. As an adult, I found the story to be rushed and so predictable that I figured out the mystery in chapter 1. Since it is Halloween season, I wanted to try a true spooky story, but I just couldn't finish because I no longer relate to teenagers as a now 30 something adult with teenage children of my own.

  • Her Halloween Treat by Tiffany Reisz: 
Contemporary Romance, Erotica, Holiday Fiction
Joey had been in what she considered to be a committed, long distance relationship with her boyfriend. She decides to surprise him by showing up at his place- except, his wife answers the door! Both women are completely shocked to discover that their prince charming had been playing them both for the past two years and neither suspected about the other woman. What better time for her brother to be getting married to the man of his dreams- it's the perfect escape for Joey. Once she arrives back to her family's hometown cabin in Oregon, her friend starts giving her sound advice for moving on from this heartbreak. And what better way to move on than under the sculpted handyman that she actually grew up with?! He wasn't always so appealing to her, but something about their chemistry feels different. Can he mend her recently broken heart, or at the very least, her wounded libido? 

I stopped reading this about 4 chapters in because I did not like the casual hookup vibes being pushed. I enjoy premarital hookups that lead to marriage because they truly fall for one another. I also didn't care too much for the LGBTQIA+ theme, but because it is a minor mention and not the focal point of the story, I believe I can read onward. I also have to know if the two MCs fall for each other.

3 Books on My TBR This Fall 📚🍂

  • The Cinnamon Spice Inn by Harper Graham: 
Contemporary Romance, RomCom, Spicy Romance
Madison is a self confessed coffee addict and food writer who is convinced that she belongs in NYC. However, life sends her back to her hometown in Maple Falls to The Cinnamon Spice Inn to save it from destruction. Her ex, Zach, is still there and, of course, he is the local handyman. Not only does he know how to perform his handywork, but he also knows exactly what buttons to push on Madison. She's the one that got away and the last thing he wants to do is be working side by side with her. Can these two put aside their hard feelings long enough to save the family business? Will they kindle a flame? 

I already read one book in the series and was hooked. So, I want to naturally continue. The spice is very minimal and just minor commentary in the beginning. The intimate acts did not even happen until the end of the book, which at that point, the MCs have already established a bond, desire, and yearn for one another. 

  • Autumn at the Cat Cafe by Kathleen Fuller: 
Cozy Romance, Christian Fiction
Via's cafe is situated nextdoor to Earl's bookstore. It should be the perfect match- for business that is. However, when Earl passes away and Via expects to take over ownership of the bookstore, an unexpected handsome heir named Leo arrives to assume his new responsibility. While Via had hopes of saving the legacy of Earl's business, Leo is hoping to sell it quick to the highest buyer, tuck his tail and run back to his life in L.A. But, the will specifically requires him to remain in town for one month to assume the inheritance. So Via tries convincing him that this bookstore is vital to the town and her business with a Fall themed bucket list. Will Leo remain unmoved or will he see the magic of this small autumn town? Is Via falling for her new bookstore neighbor?

I'm a cat obsessed feen that will read almost anything with a cat mention or cover art. Mix that with my love of Fall and it is on my TBR yesterday.

  • October Kiss by Kristen Ethridge: 
Romance, Holiday Fiction 
Ryan is a savvy businessman working on creating an app that will secure the financial future of his children, but he is sacrificing precious time with them currently. His wife passed away leaving him to care for the children alone. In order to juggle his professional and personal life, he hires a nanny named Poppy to help with the home and children. She is a single, young, and eccentric female with nothing to plant roots in. So when she leaves her yoga instructing to help care for Ryan and his children temporarily, she starts having fun and laughs all the time. The strange thing is, so does Ryan. Why is she suddenly feeling so attached to this family when her gig with them is only short term? Why does Ryan feel guilty pursuing new relationships- is it just grief or not the right person?

I watched the Hallmark movie and it is a seasonal rewatch for me every year. It gives me all the lovey, holiday feel good vibes. 

Final Thoughts 💬

Have you read any of these books I mentioned? Do you have any fall favorites you think I should read? Let's chat in the comments! My TBR is always looking for new additions 😂

No comments:

Post a Comment